Most holiday planners are garbage so I tested six of them for you

I spent four hours in the pouring rain outside a closed Airbnb in Berlin back in 2019 because I thought a color-coded Excel spreadsheet was a ‘system.’ It wasn’t. It was just a digital list of my own delusions. My phone died, the PDF wouldn’t load offline, and I couldn’t remember if the keypad code was for the front gate or the actual door. I ended up paying €240 for a last-minute room at the Hotel Adlon Kempinski just so I could cry in a bathrobe. It was the most expensive mistake of my life, and it’s why I’ve spent the last three years obsessing over finding a holiday planner that actually works when things go sideways.

The part where I admit I was wrong about TripIt

I used to think TripIt was for boring business travelers who wear those zip-off cargo pants. I was wrong. I spent two years trying to make ‘prettier’ apps work, but I keep coming back to this ugly, functional beast. The interface is as charming as a tax audit, but it is the only thing that hasn’t failed me during a connection. What I mean is—actually, let me put it differently. It’s not that it’s better at ‘planning,’ it’s that it’s better at retrieving. You forward an email, and it just works.

I tested the Pro version ($49/year) across three continents. The real-time gate change alerts usually hit my phone 4 minutes before the airport monitors update. That sounds small. It isn’t. It’s the difference between getting the last seat on a rebooked flight and sleeping on a terminal floor in Newark. If you travel more than twice a year, just pay the money.

Anyway, I once tried to explain this to my cousin who insists on using Google Calendar for everything, and she looked at me like I was joined the Flat Earth society. But Google Calendar doesn’t tell you that your terminal changed while you were mid-nap in the lounge. It just sits there, silent and useless.

Stop telling me to use Notion for travel

Close-up of a whiteboard calendar with 'FALL BREAK' written in bold letters.

I know people will disagree with me here. I know the ‘productivity influencers’ love their aesthetic travel templates with the lo-fi hip-hop vibes and the embedded Spotify playlists. But planning a trip on Notion is like trying to build a car while you’re driving it. It is too much friction. You spend six hours choosing the right cover photo for your ‘Tokyo 2024’ page and zero minutes checking if the fish market is actually open on Wednesdays.

Notion is for people who like the idea of traveling more than the actual act of being in a foreign country.

I refuse to recommend Notion for holidays. It’s a trap. I’ve seen friends get so bogged down in the ‘database’ of restaurants that they forget to actually book the flights. It’s bloated, it’s slow on mobile data, and it’s fundamentally built for desks, not for walking down a crowded street in Bangkok with a backpack on. Total waste of time.

The 18% battery drain problem

If you want a visual planner, Wanderlog is the current darling. I like it. I really do. But we need to talk about the battery. During a 12-hour walking tour of Mexico City, I tracked my iPhone 13’s battery usage. Wanderlog, with its constant GPS refreshing and heavy map interface, chewed through 18% of my battery in just under two hours of active use. That is terrifying if you don’t have a power bank.

  • Wanderlog: Best for road trips where you have a car charger.
  • TripIt: Best for flight-heavy itineraries.
  • Moleskine Voyageur: Best for when you want to feel like a 19th-century explorer (and your phone is dead).

I actually have an irrational hatred for Rick Steves’ paper planners. I know he’s a legend, but the font makes me feel like I’m 80 years old and about to complain about the price of a ham sandwich. I can’t do it. I need my gear to feel at least somewhat modern, even if it’s just a notebook.

A brief rant about ‘All-in-One’ solutions

There is no such thing. Every app that claims to do the booking, the planning, the social sharing, and the expense tracking ends up doing all of them poorly. I’d rather use three specific tools that work than one ‘super-app’ that crashes because it’s trying to load a currency converter and a weather map at the same time. The best holiday planner is usually a combination of a boring automation tool (TripIt) and a physical backup.

I’ve bought the same $28 Moleskine Voyageur four times now. I don’t care if it’s ‘redundant’ to have a paper backup. When you’re at a border crossing in the Balkans and the guard doesn’t speak English and your phone won’t connect to the local tower, having your hotel address written on actual paper is the only thing that matters. It’s worth every penny.

I’m still not sure why we do this to ourselves. Why we spend weeks of our lives organizing every thirty-minute block of a vacation just to have a bus strike or a thunderstorm ruin it anyway. Maybe the planning is just a way to handle the anxiety of leaving home. I don’t know. I’m still trying to figure out if I actually enjoy the trip or if I just enjoy the feeling of a perfectly organized itinerary.

Just buy a notebook and get TripIt Pro. Forget the rest.