Moleskine Vs Leuchtturm1917 Bullet Journaling: Moleskine vs. Leuchtturm1917: Which Notebook Wins for Bullet Journaling?

You bought a Moleskine because everyone said it was the classic. Three weeks into your bullet journal, the ink bleeds through four pages and your favorite fountain pen looks like a marker. The dots are too dark. The pages are too few. You’re frustrated.

This is the reality for thousands of students and teachers who start bullet journaling every year. They pick the wrong notebook and quit. The choice between Moleskine and Leuchtturm1917 isn’t about brand loyalty. It’s about whether your notebook will hold up to daily use for a full semester.

Here’s what you actually need to know to make that call.

Why Paper Quality Matters More Than Brand

Bullet journaling is a system built on rapid logging, collections, and migration. The paper is the foundation. If it ghosts, bleeds, or tears, the system fails. You stop trusting your notebook. You stop using it.

Moleskine uses 70 gsm paper. Leuchtturm1917 uses 80 gsm paper. That 10 gsm difference is everything.

In real terms: a standard gel pen like the Pilot G2 0.7 will ghost through Moleskine paper. You’ll see the writing from the other side. With Leuchtturm1917, the same pen leaves a faint shadow at worst. With a fine-liner like the Sakura Pigma Micron 01, Leuchtturm1917 handles it cleanly. Moleskine shows ghosting on the reverse side after two passes.

If you use fountain pens — and many bullet journalists do — Moleskine is almost unusable. A Lamy Safari with a fine nib and Noodler’s Black ink bleeds through Moleskine pages. The same setup on Leuchtturm1917 shows minor ghosting but no bleed-through.

Verdict: For any pen heavier than a ballpoint, Leuchtturm1917 wins. Moleskine paper is too thin for serious bullet journaling.

Page Count and Lifespan: How Long Will It Last?

A selection of firearms and safety gear on a table at an indoor shooting range.

A bullet journal is not a diary you fill over years. It’s a working system you replace every few months. The page count determines how often you migrate — and migration is the most painful part of the system.

Moleskine classic notebooks have 192 pages (96 sheets). Leuchtturm1917 notebooks have 249 pages (124 sheets). That’s 57 more pages — roughly 30% more space.

For a student using a bullet journal for a 15-week semester, here’s what that means:

Usage Moleskine (192 pages) Leuchtturm1917 (249 pages)
Daily rapid log (1 page/day) 105 pages used 105 pages used
Weekly spreads (2 pages/week) 30 pages used 30 pages used
Monthly spreads (2 pages/month) 10 pages used 10 pages used
Collections (habits, grades, projects) 20 pages used 20 pages used
Total pages used 165 pages 165 pages
Remaining pages 27 pages 84 pages

The Moleskine leaves you with just 27 spare pages. Any extra collections — book lists, exam schedules, habit trackers — and you’re out of space before finals. The Leuchtturm1917 gives you 84 pages of breathing room.

Verdict: Leuchtturm1917 lasts longer. If you hate migrating, get the Leuchtturm1917.

Dot Grid Design and Usability

Bullet journaling relies on the dot grid. It’s the structure that lets you draw lines, tables, and trackers without the distraction of solid lines.

Moleskine dots are 5mm apart, which is standard. But the dots themselves are dark gray — almost black. They compete with your ink. On a busy spread, the dots don’t fade into the background. They stay visible and make the page feel cluttered.

Leuchtturm1917 also uses a 5mm grid. The dots are lighter — a soft gray that disappears under most pen inks. You can draw a straight line by following the dots, but once the ink is down, the dots are barely noticeable.

Here’s the difference in practice: when you scan or photograph your bullet journal spreads (for sharing with students or posting online), Moleskine dots show up clearly in the image. Leuchtturm1917 dots fade out. Your content takes center stage.

Verdict: Leuchtturm1917 has the better dot grid. Moleskine dots are too aggressive.

Build Quality and Durability

Flat lay of school supplies including compass, notebook, pen, and sticky notes on a marble surface.

Both notebooks are hardcover. Both lie flat when opened. Both have a ribbon bookmark. These are table stakes.

Moleskine uses a stitched binding that holds up well. The cover is a stiff cardboard with a rounded spine. After three months of daily use, the corners start to fray. The elastic closure band loosens over time.

Leuchtturm1917 uses a thread-bound spine that opens completely flat — no cracking. The cover is slightly thicker than Moleskine’s. The elastic band is stronger and stays tight after a year of use. The back pocket is also larger, holding 10-15 loose sheets without bulging.

One specific difference: Moleskine includes a “In Case of Loss” notice in the front. Leuchtturm1917 does not. If you lose your notebook, that notice won’t help. It’s a gimmick.

Verdict: Leuchtturm1917 is physically tougher. Moleskine wears out faster.

Price and Value: What You Actually Pay Per Page

Moleskine classic dot grid notebook (large, 13x21cm): $19.95
Leuchtturm1917 dot grid notebook (medium, A5, 14.5x21cm): $21.95

The difference is $2.00. But the Leuchtturm1917 gives you 57 more pages.

Cost per page:
Moleskine: $0.104 per page
Leuchtturm1917: $0.088 per page

Leuchtturm1917 is actually cheaper per page. And because the paper is thicker, you can write on both sides without the back side being unusable. That doubles your effective page count.

If you factor in that Moleskine pages ghost so badly that many users only write on one side, the Leuchtturm1917 becomes significantly better value.

Verdict: Leuchtturm1917 is cheaper per usable page. Moleskine is a worse deal.

The One Reason to Buy Moleskine

Minimalist workspace setup featuring a laptop, notebooks, and design samples for productivity

I’m not going to tell you Moleskine has no place.

If you write exclusively with a pencil — a standard #2 Ticonderoga — Moleskine paper is fine. No ghosting. No bleed. The pencil erases cleanly. The dark dots don’t matter because pencil is lighter than ink.

If you are a teacher using a bullet journal for lesson planning and you only use pencil, Moleskine works. It’s also slightly more available in physical stores. You can walk into any Barnes & Noble and find a Moleskine on the shelf. Leuchtturm1917 is sometimes harder to find in person.

But that’s it. If you use any pen — ballpoint, gel, rollerball, fountain pen — the Moleskine will disappoint you.

Verdict: Buy Moleskine only if you use pencil. Otherwise, skip it.

When Not to Buy Either Notebook

Both Moleskine and Leuchtturm1917 are premium brands. They cost $20 each. If you’re a student on a tight budget, there are better options.

Rhodia Goalbook ($16.50, A5, 80 gsm paper, 224 pages) — same paper quality as Leuchtturm1917, cheaper, but only available in orange or black covers. The paper is coated, so fountain pens work beautifully. No ghosting at all.

Essentials by Dingbats ($18.00, A5, 100 gsm paper, 192 pages) — thicker paper than both Moleskine and Leuchtturm1917. No ghosting even with brush pens. The cover is vegan leather. 100 gsm is overkill for most bullet journalists, but if you use markers or watercolor, this is the choice.

Minimalism Art Classic ($12.99, A5, 100 gsm paper, 192 pages) — the budget king. Thick paper, lay-flat binding, two ribbon bookmarks. The paper is slightly cream-colored, which some people prefer for eye strain. At half the price of Leuchtturm1917, it’s the best value for students.

If you are a beginner and not sure bullet journaling will stick, do not spend $20 on a notebook. Buy a Minimalism Art Classic for $13. If you love the system after three months, upgrade to a Leuchtturm1917.

Verdict: For students on a budget, skip both. Get the Minimalism Art Classic or Rhodia Goalbook.